« This Just Beamed In | Main | The 5 Obstructions of Sam Twyford-Moore — Second Obstructions »

12/01/2011

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Fan of Sam

Dear Esteemed Seizure Eds.,

Thanks for organising this interesting exercise, and for your publication and efforts in general. A few brief questions:

- You note that "STM is all too aware that he is a writer and he is writing, and he will be read and judged by his writerly friends". What makes this a bad thing?

- You hope to help STM achieve "a natural rhythm and bring a more conversational and open style to his phrasing". What do "natural" and "open" mean here? And "conversational"? And why would achieving them be a good thing?

- You insist that "even though this is a chapter of a larger work, it must be a narrative unto itself. So the chapter must end with what we like to call a narrative tug. A question that needs answering. An event that demands a resolution". Why "must" this all be the case? And why "most importantly"?

Yours curious to hear why a magazine hoping to "create exciting and experimental projects" would cleave to such standards, especially with the expectation that they might inspire less "familiar ways of storytelling",

Concerned Reader

D

Greetings Fan of Sam, thank you for you comments. Your questions are well worth considering. We'll start this response by advising that this is an experiment that all players involved are participating in with a determined bon homie. Challenges are set based on our personal impressions of the writing and in discussion with STM, who we all love and admire.

The first point you raise, is it a bad thing that STM remains aware of his social environment? Not at all, but is it inhibiting his writing and freedom of expression? We think it is. In early discussion with STM it was generally agreed that this self-awareness was limiting his writing, mainly due to pre-editing, and thus not fully extending himself. The challenge is not set to disparage the context, his friends or the awesome literary crowd around him, but that the awareness of such millieu sculpts what he writes about and how clever his sentences need to be.
Similarly, this entire exercise, and the public nature thereof is aimed squarely at busting down the fear of judgment that impedes most of us as writers.

Next up, 'natural' and 'open'. Tis good to ask, and it is definitely a matter of subjectivity, but also that STM is like most of us, and we observe this all the time, he speaks more fluidly and candidly in dialogue than he does in his writing. In conversation we often aren't perfect and this leads to more unguarded thoughts and sentences; whose flaws and untrained sentiments and subtext reveal more of a person's character, background and motivations than in written form. We just want STM to loosen up his grip. Let it flow, man.

Lastly, why, oh why, when trying to bring a nature of experiment to this writing game are we pushing STM towards a tired old narrative convention? The aim of the game is to push STM from his comfort zone. With his considered background and literary awareness. Like many of his contemporaries who strive for originality like it is the holy grail, they become more bound by the effort ignore handy storytelling techniques than the freedom they strive for.
The shorter answer is to make us the reader want to read the next chapter. Whether you are a writer who wants to sell a lot of books or a writer that wants to be appreciated, to challenge readers to continue reading even though bored and disengaged from the story seems odd.
So the challenge is to help STM get over this prejudice and add this tool to his toolbox.

Tell us more about these "unfamiliar ways of storytelling.' What did you have in mind?

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.